Child Compensation: €25,000 injury claim award for cut knee

by | Mar 27, 2013 | Personal Injury


In the Circuit Court last week Judge Matthew Deery heard that a child sued through her mother following an injury to her right knee after an accident at a crèche in Dublin.

The accident happened to Ellen Hackett, of Hazelwood Court, Artane, Dublin, when she was kneeling on a floor on broken glass back in June 2011. The child taken to Temple Street Hospital for treatment after sustaining a deep cut to her knee in the course of the accident at the crèche which had left her with a scar. In Court counsel for the child, who is now aged six, said the owners of the crèche at Artane Beaumont Family Recreation Centre had agreed to The Injuries Board assessing compensation for the injury. Even where this is the case in situations of compensation involving a minor, compensation awards issued by the Injuries Board must be approved by the Courts. Judge Matthew Deery approved the Injuries Board’s assessment of €25,000 damages together with out-of-pocket expenses plus legal costs.

Compensation Claims of behalf of a Child

If a child has been involved in a civil action for example for an accident or a claim for an injury, a child (under eighteen known in law as a minor) is not in a position to bring an action to Court in their own right while they are still a minor. Proceedings are usually issued by their parent or guardian as “next friend” on their behalf.  Solicitors are frequently approached by parents in such circumstances where their child has had an accident and they are unsure as to what the legal position is e.g. when their child is involved in a car or road accident or as in this instance sustained an accident at a crèche for example. These claims also differ in that the approval of the Court must be first sought before any settlement offered in compensation is accepted. Furthermore any compensation agreed between the parties in settlement must first be ruled by the Court before such a settlement is finalized including in Injuries Board matters. These applications are known as infant rulings. The child compensation is then held by the Court until the child reaches the age of eighteen.

*Carmody Moran Solicitors advise the parents or guardians as to their legal rights and how an case / court action can be brought on behalf of a child following a road traffic or other accident and do so in a comprehensive, confidential manner. Our aim is to listen, understand and to put right what we can in order to secure justice for our clients. For a friendly free chat about child compensation, please telephone our personal injury solicitors on 01 827 2888 or use our contact form here

Regulation of Child Care Providers in Ireland

In Ireland crèches are regulated by The Child Care (Pre-School Services) (No 2) Regulations 2006 and the Child Care (Pre-School Services) (No 2) (Amendment) Regulations 2006 made under Part VII of the Child Care Act 1991. The Regulations include an Explanatory Guide to Requirements and Procedures for Notification and Inspection which offers guidance on good practice in relation to child care providers of pre-school services. The Regulations detail matters such as the information that should be given to parents about details of the service such as

  • the adult/child ratios
  • maximum numbers of children
  • their age ranges
  • the type of the care facilities at issue

They also say that the child care provider or crèche should ensure that there is adequate insurance against injury for the children while attending the service.

Image Credit: Wikimedia


review us on
Very professional experienced team who run a friendly and efficient practice. I found them to be very astute and knowledgeable in our discussions about Litigation. Their advice made me rethink my actions and helped me settle an issue without any unnecessary actions or outlays.
Response from the owner: Dear Michael. Thank you for your positive review of our legal services at Carmody Moran Solicitors, Blanchardstown office. We will always do our utmost to ensure that we meet our client's expectations and to give them prompt and practical legal advice in all our areas of legal practice whether that be family law, property sales and purchases, probate or litigation. I have passed on your comments to the team and they are all delighted that you were happy with our legal service to you. Best regards, Tony, Niamh and all the team at Carmody Moran Solicitors, Blanchardstown.
We recently purchased our house through Carmody Moran and they were great to deal with. They were there each step of the way and really helped close the purchase within a short time frame. Thanks for everything!
Response from the owner: Dear Benjamin. Thank you so much for the positive review of our property purchase service through our Blanchardstown office. We all hope that you have settled well into your new home! Best regards, Niamh Moran and all the team at Carmody Moran Solicitors
Carmody Moran performed the conveyancing for my apartment purchase. My solicitor Caila Ryan was extremely diligent and professional. She did a great job guiding me through the process and offering advice. I really appreciated all of the documentation she provide me with. I would have no hesitation in recommending them.
Response from the owner: Dear Ciaran, I passed on the very welcome and positive review of our solicitor, Caila Ryan's assistance to you when buying your apartment. It is always great to hear back such positive feedback of our property purchase services and thanks for taking the time to do so. Best regards, Niamh Moran and all the team at Carmody Moran Solicitors.